Archive for May 28th, 2012

Senate asked: Vote based on conscience, evidence

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:52 pm

MANILA (8th Update, 4:55 p.m.) – Ending the closing arguments of the prosecution panel, House Speaker Feliciano Belmonte Jr. pleaded to the impeachment tribunal to vote on the case against Chief Justice Renato Corona based on conscience and the evidence presented.

“I ask that you vote according to conscience, and the evidence. Find Chief Justice Corona guilty,” Belmonte, a “surprise” speaker for the prosecution team’s closing arguments, said. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

Defense challenges impeach complaint validity

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:51 pm

MANILA (6th Update, 4:15 p.m.) – Lawyers of Chief Justice Renato Corona challenged anew Monday before the Senate impeachment court the validity of the complaint filed against the chief magistrate.

Defense lead counsel Serafin Cuevas said they find nothing in the impeachment complaint that states the 188 congressmen who signed it were convened at any time. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

Senate told: Don’t allow Corona to get away with mere alibis

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:50 pm

MANILA (5th Update, 4:01 p.m.) – While Chief Justice Renato Corona’s lawyers want him acquitted, the prosecution appealed to the impeachment court not to allow the chief magistrate to get away with mere alibis.

“He should be removed as a Chief Justice,” Ilocos Norte Representative Rodolfo Fariñas, the deputy lead prosecutor, said in his argument before the Senate impeachment court Monday. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

‘Minor breach of law, not impeachable offense’

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:49 pm

MANILA (4th Update, 3:23 p.m.) – Lawyers of Chief Justice Renato Corona asked the Senate impeachment court Monday to acquit Corona, stressing he should not be removed from office for a minor breach of law.

Granting, for the sake of argument, that he failed to publicly disclose some of his properties and cash deposits, lawyer Eduardo delos Angeles, former dean of the Ateneo de Manila Law School, said this lapse is not punishable by removal from post. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

Prosecution: Corona no longer fit to head Judiciary

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:48 pm

MANILA (2nd Update, 2:53 p.m.) – The prosecution panel reiterated in its argument Monday that Chief Justice Renato Corona is no longer fit to head the Judiciary “for all the wrongs” that he has done while in office.

Lead prosecutor and Iloilo Representative Niel Tupas said his team and the Filipino people are convinced that Corona lied under oath to the wealth that he could not explain. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

High Court likely to debate Corona petition

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:47 pm

THE Supreme Court (SC) may moot the petition of Chief Justice Renato Corona to stop the Senate impeachment court from probing his bank deposits in view of the magistrate’s unconditional waiver over his bank accounts.

The Senate, sitting as an impeachment court, is expected to take a vote today, Tuesday, on whether or not to convict Corona on three remaining articles of impeachment. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

Bishops pray for objective Corona verdict

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 12:46 pm

A MEMBER of Permanent Council of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) is hoping that the senator-judges of the impeachment court would decide based on the evidence and not on politics.

“I hope the senators will base it on the evidence of both parties and not on politics or on whether one is an ally or not of the present government,” said Tagbilaran Bishop Leonardo Medroso in an interview over Church-run Radyo Veritas on Monday. (Read more)

Filed Under: News

Seares: Why Corona would not survive

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 05:33 am

CONVICTED or acquitted, Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona wouldn’t survive the ordeal of impeachment.

If convicted, he’d lose his position as the highest magistrate, with privileges and all else he forfeits under the law. (Read more)

Filed Under: Commentary

Malilong: Learning from the impeachment trial

Posted by on May 28, 2012 at 05:31 am

I THINK it was former Vice President Noli de Castro who first asked the question: by how many votes did Jessica Sanchez lose to Philip Phillips in the American Idol balloting? I’m not sure if a group of US-based Filipinos heard him, too, but they are now asking the show’s producers to release the number of votes received by each finalist. Holy cow, what will they do next, demand a recount?

I am raising the issue because today, hopefully, the impeachment proceedings against Chief Justice Renato Corona will finally be laid to rest. Regardless of how the senator-judges vote on Corona’s fate, we should be mature enough to respect it. (Read more)

Filed Under: Commentary

Featured Video

Prosecution press conference after the guilty verdict on Chief Justice Renato Corona on Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Popular Posts

How the Senator-Judges voted on Article II (Concealing of some of his properties and cash deposits in his SALN
Senators Vote
Edgardo J. Angara
Edgardo J. Angara

GUILTY

"I may grant the CJ plea of honest mistake of judgment but given his broad experience in public law…this willful and deliberate admission together with magnitude of amounts involved amounts to culpable violation."

Joker P. Arroyo
Joker P. Arroyo

NOT GUILTY

"Impeachment is a political process not a political assassination"

Alan Peter Compañero S. Cayetano
Alan Peter S. Cayetano

GUILTY

"If your client cannot explain, I cannot abstain."
If you did not disclose, we have to depose. If you are not fit, you cannot sit.


Pia S. Cayetano
Pia S. Cayetano

GUILTY

"Minor inaccuracies in the SALN...would not amount to betrayal of public trust. But, the failure to declare 2.4 million dollars and some P80 Million pesos is not minor...Once that trust is gone, we must step down to preserve the integrity of the position we hold."

Miriam Defensor Santiago
Miriam Defensor Santiago

NOT GUILTY

"An omission in good faith in the SALN carries a light penalty, and is even allowed to be corrected.  Thus, it is not impeachable...I find it reprehensible that the AMLA document was introduced in evidence, without authentication, as required by the Rules of Evidence."

Franklin M. Drilon
Franklin M. Drilon

GUILTY

"Where our Constitution and our laws require disclosure, he chose the path of concealment. He has lost his moral fitness to serve the people. He has betrayed the public trust. He cannot be Chief Justice a minute longer. "

Juan Ponce Enrile
Juan Ponce Enrile

GUILTY

"With all due respect, I believe that the Respondent Chief Justice's reliance on the absolute confidentiality accorded to foreign currency deposits under Section 8 of Republic Act No. 6426 is grossly misplaced."

Francis 'Chiz' Escudero
Francis G. Escudero

GUILTY

"Ang pinagbabawalan ng FCDU law na mag-release ng impormasyon ukol sa dollar deposits ay ang mga bangko at di ang depositor. Samantala, ang Konstitusyon at R.A. 6713, pinag-uutos na ideklara ng lahat ng opisyal ng pamahalaan ang lahat ng kanilang yaman at pagkakautang. Kung ayaw mo ito ideklara, eh di huwag kang tumakbo para sa, o tumanggap ng anumang, pwesto sa pamahalaan. "

Jinggoy Ejercito Estrada
Jinggoy Estrada

GUILTY

"I regret to say that I am not convinced. Because the Chief Justice is a learned man of law. He is in fact, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court - isang opisyal na hindi lamang malalim ang kaalaman sa batas, kundi isang opisyal na may tungkuling basahin kung ano ang ibig sabihin ng mga batas."

Teofisto 'TG' Guingona III
Teofisto Guingona III

GUILTY

"We must protect sanctity of Constitution. Corona's non-disclosure of assets is constitutional perversion in its ultimate form."

Gregorio 'Gringo' Honasan
Gregorio B. Honasan II

GUILTY

"We have not proven if the defendant is corrupt. What is clear is that he is no longer fit to preside over the SC."

Panfilo M. Lacson
Panfilo M. Lacson

GUILTY

"Chief Justice Renato Corona used to work as a senior officer of the tax and corporate counseling group of the tax division of a prominent accounting firm, Sycip Gorres and Velayo and Company. He also taught commercial law, taxation and corporate law at the Ateneo de Manila University for 17 years. I find it hard to believe his testimony that he does not understand accounting."

Manuel 'Lito' M. Lapid
Manuel M. Lapid

GUILTY

"Akala ko totooo ang sinabi niya hindi pala. Pinapaniwalaan ko pa si Congressman Fariñas."

Loren Legarda
Loren B. Legarda

GUILTY

"Truthful SALN disclosure is key element of transparent governance..Public trust is earned through transparent, often voluntary, gestures of honesty by officials in question."

Ferdinand Marcos
Ferdinand R. Marcos, Jr.

NOT GUILTY

"The Chief Justice sufficiently addressed the accusations against him with regard to the filing of his SALN, and the disclosure of his real properties and peso and dollar deposits."

Sergio R. Osmeña III
Sergio R. Osmeña III

GUILTY

"There is more reason to apply the law when the assets in question amount to P180 million...Nowhere in that FCDU law not allow depositors from disclosing their deposits."

Kiko Pangilinan
Francis "Kiko" Pangilinan

GUILTY

"As a lawyer and an officer of the court, it pains and saddens me to say that clearly the Chief Justice displayed a disturbing pattern of dishonesty, willful concealment, and evasion and a blatant and wanton disregard of the provisions of the Constitution on the SALN...Respect for the rule of law will only be realized if punishment is swift in a fair trial."

Aquilino Martin
Aquilino“Koko” Pimentel III

GUILTY

"There is evidence on record that shows respondent Corona didn't declare in his SALNs his properties. Arguments of respondent do not persuade this senator-judge."

Ralph G. Recto
Ralph G. Recto

GUILTY

"The undeclared assets are so huge that it cannot be pressed aside as innocent exclusion"

Ramon 'Bong' <br />  						Revilla, Jr
Ramon Revilla, Jr.

GUILTY

"Through his own direct admission, the Chief Justice failed to properly disclose all his assets in SALN"

Vicente C. Sotto III
Vicente C. Sotto III

GUILTY

" True judgment must come from the people"

 

Antonio F. Trillanes IV
Antonio F.  Trillanes IV

GUILTY

"The claim of commingled funds and confidentiality of dollar deposits will never be accepted as alibis. From now on, no one's untouchable. "

Manny Villar
Manny Villar

GUILTY

"Nahirapan man ako sa aming desisyon, paniwala ko kailangan talaga ideklara and dollar accounts."